I never did actually write anything on here about the topic of disagreement, but I wrote an essay on the subject, and this week I submitted it to Karl to finish one of my courses (ED: you ask how I submitted it to finish a course in mid-late February? That’s just how things work around these parts). Structurally, the paper is a mess, and it falls well short of what I’d aim for in a complete treatment of the topic, but I think the ideas are not all bad.
I’m posting the paper for anyone who wants to read it. Buyer beware. Also, since it’s unfinished work, I’ll probably take it down at some point, when I either start revising or put the topic on the back burner. As you might guess, it’s not to be redistributed or cited, but I’d be happy to hear comments, either here or by email.